Huggy Wuggy & Kissy Missy left Poppy Playtime in Monika's care before going to the cinema. After her initial friendly appearance, she quickly revealed her true colors, ordering Poppy to stay out of her way, go to bed early and to do the dishes. Poppy protested, only to be threatened by her showing his parents a copy of a "Rare Magazine" allegedly belonging to her, noting that her blackmail worked on her friends. (Yuri, Natsuki, & Sayori.) Poppy reluctantly agreed to do the dishes, only to be rewarded with a slice of anchovy pizza, which made her faint.

Monika awakened Poppy in her bedroom, saying it was bedtime. Poppy's protest was met by her suggestion that she watch her favorite show, The World of Lip Gloss. Her refusal made her leave the room while cackling. Poppy asked her Magic 8-Ball when Huggy & Kissy will return, which it answered with Never, Haha!. Frustrated, She threw the ball at the wall, where it split in half and released a magic aura, acting as the entrance of Cosmo and Wanda, her fairy godparents.

Poppy almost called the police before the pair told her it was against Da Rules. Their explanation of what they did was interrupted by Monika bursting into the room, wanting to know what's going on. She noticed the fishbowl with Poppy's fairies and claimed they were ridden with germs and that she would flush them.

Poppy noticed the fairies' ability to grant wishes, immediately wishing for trouble to Monika. She wished her bath water into Jell-O, turned her into a fly, ordered a giant baby Wanda to sit on her, teleported her to space with her fairies chasing her with TIE fighters, and eventually she was tied to some train tracks, where Poppy threatened her to apologize before train Cosmo runs over her.

Huggy & Kissy woke up Monika as if she had a nightmare, and offered to drive her home. Poppy asked Kissy to have Monika babysit her all the time, to which the fairies said they'll be with her for a while.